Our friend group had a great trip to the Shenandoah over New Year's weekend. The cabin was at the top of a hill with wonderful views. The dogs frolicked on the property, and came home pooped. The house was clean and had all the amenities we needed. The owners were kind enough to leave the lights on and the doors unlocked since we were arriving after dark. The house was heated up and the hot tub was ready to go.
My only suggestion would be that the owners produce a pdf that can be sent to future renters when they book. For instance, we didn't know we needed to bring sheets and towels until a few hours before we headed that way. Also, it would be nice if some firewood were included, or perhaps some advice on where to purchase (other than walmart for $6 for a small amount).
Otherwise, it was a lovely trip to the Shenandoah. Many thanks!