This was our 2nd choice in Yelapa, but it ended up being better than 2nd best! The bed was super comfortable and we both slept really well despite the heat (in part thanks to the ocean breeze, amplified by a fan). Other than a good night's sleep and comfortable room, we weren't looking for much.
This place has its own little private beach, which was actually very nice if you don't feel like going to the big beach. Bring your own beer and snacks and have a picnic! We also visited the rooftop lounge very briefly where Kendra and Fernando were entertaining friends (or relatives?) but they were very friendly, invited us to join them and offered us beer and agua fresca.
If you want to stay "in town", I would highly recommend this place, which is very reasonably priced (especially during the off season!)More