We’ve been going to Tortuga’s for the last five or six years and the food has always been good. This year I ordered one of their daily specials with tuna and ordered it medium rare. It came out medium well and I usually don’t send food back but decided to because it wasn’t cheap. It took a while to get the waitress to come back to the table to ask for it to be taken back. The dish that came out was medium, but I wasn’t about to wait for another one. We also tried the conch fritters... avoid at all costs. Lastly and I know this wasn’t much in their control, but they allowed the table behind us to become raucous during the time we were there. They drank several bottles of wine, beer and liquor and progressively got louder and louder with yelling, screeching and what not. We left with headaches and have decided that next year we won’t be going back and will find another place to become our beach favorite.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.