Pizza is great! Thin crust, cozy respite in from the cold today. Staff is friendly and welcoming. One of our favorite stops in Greenport.
1 - 10 of 87 reviews
The BnB we staying at (Bridge&Main) recommended 1943 on a night where we wanted something casual but delicious and this place was spot on! We ordered the meatballs (do not miss these!) and one of the special pies which was out of this world. We...More
Charred crispy crusts are topped with a tasteful assortment of well-prepared toppings. Eat-in or take out. In warm weather nice to sit in the square.
Finally got to try 1943 pizza bar for lunch today.. well worth the wait.. perfect lunch spot after walking around Greenport. Thin crusted brick oven pizza reminiscent of trattorias in Italy. We had a classic margherita with added prosciutto and a white pie with spicy...More
We had a delicious appetizer which we all split. I don't remember the name of it as I did not order it. But, it was fabulous. My sister-in-law and niece had had it there before and loved it. My one sister and I had a...More
We were actually looking for "Brix & Rye." When we finally found it, it turned out to be a rather dark basement bar, of which "1943 Pizza Bar" is the above-ground, more chic section. We stayed and had a really good pizza, as well as...More
Really enjoyed the pizza here. Had the Classic Margarita pizza with a few add ons. Service was friendly and attentive. Small place, not many tables and they only seat 2-3 per table. Have seating outside more suitable for groups. Nice location in Greenport, within walking...More
I wrote a review last year and nothing has changed! It's still as great, love the thin crust, meatballs are amazing..........we will do no take out pizza from anywhere else in the Greenport area!
We had a good time at this restaurant located in the heart of Greenport. This was a Saturday night and the place was very crowded, but after waiting 10-15 minutes for a table we were served quickly. My wife and I both liked our choice...More