We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Ratings and reviews



Italian, Pizza
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner, Lunch
Reviews (22)
Filter reviews
22 results
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year
Traveller rating
See what travellers are saying:
Selected filters
Updating list...
Reviewed 30 November 2019 via mobile

Great Italian food in a little riverside village. Customer service is second to none. Been going here for over 5 years. Great cannolis

Date of visit: November 2019
Reviewed 8 January 2016

Ordered a pizza tonight with two toppings, got home, picked the pizza up and the cheese as well as toppings slid right off. Also, it wasn't even cut. I figured I'd try pizza for once, since the baked ziti is never served how I order...it. You'd think sauce would come with the meal, but even if you ask for it and stress extra sauce, you barely get any. It is very disappointing that II Castello's is the only Italian restaurant in the region. My review of service, is based on the take out system because I only order food to go. They need a number system, rather than just asking a room full of people crowded in front of the dining room and bathrooms for the last four digits of their phone number. So my review of the service is based on the take-out system.More

Date of visit: January 2016
Reviewed 8 February 2015

the food and pizza here is great, but I would not recommend this establishment to anyone. The staff is nasty, short and seems bothered that you're there. If you're sitting at a table, expect to remind the staff that you need to order, that you...did order, what your order was and that you will need to pay for whatever it is you ordered.More

Date of visit: August 2014
Reviewed 2 December 2014

We visit II Castello's about twice a month. My favorite is their calzones!! A medium size is enough for two meals for me! They have a nice salad bar (always fresh) and with a bowl of their homemade soup - it is a great lunch....Their pizza is excellent, with so many varieties to choose from. A busy place everytime we visit. The staff is very helpful and friendly. A great place to go!More

Date of visit: November 2014
Reviewed 2 December 2014

Food is always great, however it may take you 10 minutes after your seated to have anyone take a drink order. This happens each and every time I visit this restaurant.

Date of visit: November 2014
Reviewed 12 November 2014

While touring the Poconos in PA last weekend, my wife and I discovered a wonderful Italian Family Restaurant on the PA/NY border in Barryville, NY. Not only is the food great and the menu very extensive, but the owners (Peter and Kelly...there are also many...other family members working at the restaurant) couldn't have been nicer and went out of their way to make us feel like we were part of their family. The restaurant isn't much from the outside but once you get seated you will very much enjoy your dining experience. This is real Italian cooking from real Italian folks.More

Date of visit: November 2014
Reviewed 30 August 2014

Took 20 mins to get an order and another 30 mins to get two fried entrees! The French onion was watered down and nasty and the tomato soup burned my lips from the acid. Manager was nasty. We told them were not paying and left!

Date of visit: August 2014
Reviewed 18 August 2014

We found the food good and reasonable for the large portions. The service was a little slow, especially since there were only a few tables occupied.

Date of visit: August 2014
Reviewed 3 May 2014

I first had linguni with white clam sauce was mostly garlic no clams , then had calamari that was cold and tough, I have eaten there plenty of times and they are very rude not even to try to compensate u for no clams or...hold your food when u left it there untouched to go , all they could say, Pete said what do you want me to do, it was my problem, and to top it off I watched him make a pizza answer the phone and take cash all at the same time with no gloves, Pete is the owner also rude and nasty , also my aunt and her friend has received green molded pizza a few times, I think I have had enough of this place, this is very true story, bye ,bye ill Castellos, I will be sure to tell everyone not to go there againMore

Date of visit: May 2014
Reviewed 18 June 2013

My fiance and I go there often just over the bridge from pa. We went on a few first couple of dates there and loved the food all the time. They have a wide variety and most of the time will take custom pizza orders...too. We requested a chicken Alfredo pizza and it was awesome! I also like their chicken ceaser salad pizza and garlic knots. I always enjoy their food! It does get packed Friday through Sundays especially in the summer b/c it is one of the only good restaurants around! :-)More

Date of visit: June 2013
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
All Breeze Guest House
5 reviews
3.60 km away
Woodloch Pines Resort
1 779 reviews
14.96 km away
The Lodge at Woodloch
1 528 reviews
15.42 km away
Rodeway Inn Milford - I-84
80 reviews
17.46 km away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
B.V.H. Sports Bar
41 reviews
.23 km away
Rohmans Inn
24 reviews
.52 km away
Il Castello
49 reviews
.00 km away
Clancy's Coffee Shop
20 reviews
.64 km away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Minisink Battlefield County Park
22 reviews
4.87 km away
Roebling Aqueduct Suspension Bridge
108 reviews
5.59 km away
Shrewd Fox Brewery
6 reviews
5.86 km away
Reber River Trips
7 reviews
.66 km away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Il Castello's staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Il Castello's

Yes, Il Castello's offers takeaway services.

Yes, Il Castello's offers delivery services.

Il Castello's is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travellers:
  • Food: 4
  • Service: 3
  • Value: 3.5
  • Atmosphere: 3.5