We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travellers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travellers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
Small shop with different jarred peanut butter flavors including treats, cookies, syrups and chocolate goodies. They even have treats for your dog. I always stop in when visiting Cape May and bring something back home with me!
Enjoy a PB&J Sandwich and a french pressed coffee, Caramel Pecan was delish!
I Love this shop!
Most unique food/goodies for yourself and gift giving. Excellent prices for (mostly) housemade products.
Most Helpful employees assisting you throughout the store, even helpful suggestions for what to...do/where to visit while in CM!
Happiest Place In Cape May for sure.More
I’ve been following Cape May Peanut Butter Co. on FB for a few years, ever since we started going to Cape May for some long weekend getaways a few years ago. The first time we tried the peanut butter we were hooked.
A few weeks...ago I saw them advertise a Small Batch Malted Chocolate Peanut Butter. We were in Cape May and as soon as I saw that jar, I had to have it!
As soon as we got home, before I even unpacked, I tried it - it’s so good! I’m sorry I only bought 1 jar. So now I’m hiding it so I don’t have to share it with my husband....More
I’d never ordered any of the baked products at this wonderful store until today. I overheard the owner talk about the cookies being fresh from the oven, and they smelled tantalizing. I tried three different kinds: (1) peanut butter chip and chocolate chip (very good),...(2) dark chocolate cookie with nuts (better than very good), and (3) peanut butter cookie with a “Reese’s-type” bar on top (outrageously delicious!). I am a new fan of the fresh cookies at this store.More
OMG try the butterscotch and the capucino (spelled like the label) this stuff is addicting. We stopped at the peanut butter co next door to cape may brewery and I purchased 2 assortments, one as a gift and one for me. I just finished the...capucino on triscuits and the person we gave the other assortment to ate 2 jars while watching a 30 minute show!! Love their peanut butter!!More