We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
  • Sorted by: Ranking
We found great results, but some are outside Shelter Island. Showing results in neighbouring cities.
Limit search to Shelter Island.
Sailacat Boat Charters Sag Harbor 7.3 km away
#1 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
#1 of 1 Tours in Shelter Island Heights
Vintage Tours Greenport, NY 12.4 km away
#1 of 13 Tours in Greenport
Peconic Water Sports Southold, NY 6.3 km away
#1 of 4 Tours in Southold
GLORY Greenport, NY 5.2 km away
#2 of 13 Tours in Greenport
Sag Harbor Charters Sag Harbor 7.2 km away
#2 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Fish North Fork Southold, NY 7.4 km away
#2 of 4 Tours in Southold
North Fork Wine Tours Greenport, NY 6.0 km away
#3 of 13 Tours in Greenport
American Beauty Cruises & Charters Sag Harbor 7.0 km away
#3 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Virgin Star Sailing Adventures Greenport, NY 5.1 km away
#4 of 13 Tours in Greenport
Sail-Works Branford, CT 7.0 km away
#4 of 5 Tours in Branford
Dove Sailing Charters Sag Harbor 7.3 km away
#4 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Eagle's Neck Paddling Company Southold, NY 6.7 km away
#4 of 4 Tours in Southold
East End Charters Llc Greenport, NY 6.0 km away
#5 of 13 Tours in Greenport
#5 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Wine Tour New York Greenport, NY 6.5 km away
#6 of 13 Tours in Greenport
Sea Escapes Sag Harbor Sag Harbor 7.0 km away
#6 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Peconic Cruise Line Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#7 of 13 Tours in Greenport
Sag Harbor Sailing Sag Harbor 7.4 km away
#7 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Peconic Star Fleet Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#8 of 13 Tours in Greenport
Li Vino Tours Greenport, NY 5.4 km away
#9 of 13 Tours in Greenport
Peconic Water Sports Sag Harbor 7.8 km away
#9 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Shaka Flyboarding Greenport, NY 5.2 km away
#10 of 13 Tours in Greenport